Post image for Caution: Major TEABS ahead on Jellicoe Road

Caution: Major TEABS ahead on Jellicoe Road

by Poshdeluxe on March 19, 2010

REPORT CARD for Jellicoe Road by Melina Marchetta

bff charm: yay!
swoonworthy scale: 9
talky talk: prosetastic
bonus factors: mysterious loner dude, boarding school, territory wars
relationship status: eternal love

jellicoe_road

the deal:

Although it may look like yr average scenic route, Jellicoe Road is a magical place that, like Gretchen Weiners’ hair, is full of secrets. And for Taylor Markham, those mysteries include the key to her past, present and future. See, when Taylor was a kid, she was abandoned on Jellicoe Road by her mother, and she’s been raised among other orphans at the Jellicoe School. Now that she’s finally a senior, Taylor has been chosen to serve as the head of her house and given the responsibility of looking after the younger students and, more importantly, waging the summer territory wars against the Cadets (boys in military training, kinda like the Australian version of ROTC) and the Townies (the kids who live in town). In spite of the weight of these duties, Taylor finds herself deeply disturbed by the sudden departure of her mentor, Hannah, and the manuscript she left behind, which tells the tragic tale of five people who met their destinies on Jellicoe Road. Haunted by this enigmatic story, Taylor begins a quest to find out what happened to the five (Fitz, Jude, Narnie, Webb and Tate) in the hopes of discovering the truth about her own identity. Complicating matters further (as if the girl didn’t have enough crap to deal with!) is the fact that the head of the cadets is none other than Jonah Griggs, a boy who shares a piece of Taylor’s dark past.

bff charm: yay!

bff

Taylor Markham is one tough cookie, you guys. In fact, she kind of scares me sometimes. I’d probably stand nervously by her locker and, as she rounded the corner of the hall, totally lose my nerve to talk to her, let alone give her my bff charm, because she’s so dang BAD ASS. Scarred by her elusive, beautiful mother, Taylor has pretty much walled herself away from intimacy with anyone, and her guarded toughness only makes girls like me want to be her friend even more, especially cos it’s obvious girlfriend needs a marathon heart to heart session over a pint of Ben & Jerry’s. Fortunately, she’s already got a BFF named Raffy (who i also love love LOVE), but Taylor could definitely use a few more bosom buddies. It’s painful to read about her tortured longing for a sense of family, a feeling of *belonging* somewhere, and lines like this– Because people with that much spirit frighten me the hell out of me. They make me want to be a better person when I know it’s not possible– just made me want to reach out and grab her in a hug, even though she’d probably beat me up afterwards.

swoonworthy scale: 9

My reading list been experiencing a bit of a dry spell in the swoon department lately, and Jellicoe Road brought enough rain to float Noah’s ark. LORD ALMIGHTY is there some Epic Level Hotness in this book. The chemistry between Taylor and Jonah is absolutely *scorching* from the first minute Taylor lays eyes on Jonah’s… boots (let’s just say, their reunion is NOT friendly, i.e. did someone order a hot heaping plate of TENSION?!!). I’ll be sighing more over Jonah in the bonus factor category, but I can tell you right now, their relationship has immediately leaped into my top five YA romances of all time. Y’ALL THAT IS A SERIOUS PROMOTION. There’s obviously some sizzling physical attraction between the two, but what makes Taylor and Jonah’s connection so powerful is the tragic pasts they share and their subsequent struggles to keep hope from cracking through their mutually cynical exteriors.

talky talky: prosetastic

I’ve read two of Marchetta’s previous books, and while i enjoyed the pants out of them, i found Jellicoe Road to be her most beautifully written work so far. While all of the characters are carefully and authentically developed, Taylor’s voice especially rings true in a way that made my heart soar with her triumphs and break with her descents into darkness. Here’s just one example of the gut punches you can expect from Marchetta’s writing:

I fight hard to stay afloat and suddenly I remember the feeling of fear in my mother’s touch. Some say it’s impossible because you remember nothing when you’re five seconds old but I promise you this: I remember the tremble in my mother’s body when the midwife first placed me in her arms. I remember the feeling of slipping between those fingers. It’s like she never really managed to grab hold of me with a firmness that spoke of never letting go. It’s like she never got it right.

GAH! I know, right?!! My only complaint about the structure of this book are the flashbacks to the five kids in Hannah’s manuscript. When you first begin the story, it’s not clear who exactly these kids are or why their parts are always written in italics. Plus i had a hard time keeping up with who was who (blame the Australian names, aka “Ooooh, Tate is a GIRL?!!”). In spite of some early bumps, Marchetta manages to skillfully weave their lives into Taylor’s, and the end result was definitely worth my initial confusion.

bonus factor: mysterious loner dude

jordancatalano

Jonah Griggs is totally the new Cameron Quick, you guys. AND YOU KNOW I DON’T SAY THAT LIGHTLY. He’s brooding, he’s fit (thank you, military push-ups!) and most importantly, he’s a total enigma. Other boys fear him, while girls constantly offer up their phone numbers, but Jonah remains an island off the coast of Super Hot Mystique. And, unlike Jordan “I can’t read good” Catalano, Jonah’s secrets only made me fall in love with him more. Warning: you should consider every page that he’s on to be *highly flammable*.

bonus factor: boarding school

boardingschool

Even though the Jellicoe School is lacking in certain boarding school qualities, such as rich kids and designer clothes, it more than makes up for it with the Harry-Potter-style house system and major dramz.

bonus factor: territory wars

capture_the_flag

Let me break this down for you right here: a territory war is like capture the flag, except WAY MORE EPIC. The Cadets, the Townies and the Jellicoe School kids have been playing this game for years, and every inch of space, down to specific trees, is fought over by the three groups and carefully mapped out. The extremely complex rules are outlined in a purple rule book and argued over extensively by the three group leaders during secret negotiation meetings. Students are kidnapped, individuals are ambushed, and it’s basically the coolest thing EVER. In fact, I totally want to set up a real life Territory Wars because I am dying to play. Who’s with me?!! We could fight the hipsters and take over a bar! Water balloons may be involved.

casting call:

I love these characters so much, I gotta go with my typical favorites:

kat dennings as taylor

kat dennings as taylor

She’s gorgeous, but would you want to mess with her? I don’t think so.

taylor kitsch as jonah

taylor kitsch as jonah

Hot loner dude? Like I was gonna go with anyone else!

relationship status: eternal love

If you couldn’t already tell, I AM IN L-O-V-E WITH THIS BOOK (that includes you, Jonah! p.s. CALL ME). And you should be, too, which is why I’m adding it to my top YAngelism tools. This book is brimming with two of my favorite YA elements, swoons and mischief, but more importantly, it’s a masterfully written, heartbreakingly beautiful story about a girl struggling not only to find herself, but to embrace herself. The minute I finished the last page, I wanted to read it all over again (and I actually did go back and read my favorite parts a few more times cos we’re talking *serious* case of TEABS here). I’m dying to take all of you with me back to Jellicoe Road, so if you know what’s good for you, READ THIS BOOK IMMEDIATELY. And then sign up to be on my territory wars team cos we are totally gonna kick the shizz out of those hipsters.

Share

Related posts:

  1. Alt+F4

{ 8 trackbacks }

the most swoonworthy YA couples of all time
April 7, 2010 at 12:48 pm
rock out with yr sword out
May 21, 2010 at 9:36 am
forever young (adult) i want to be forever young (adult) «
June 2, 2010 at 8:41 pm
forever young adult presents: yangelistic offerings to world leaders and crackpots
February 9, 2011 at 10:22 am
he just smiled and gave me a vegemite sandwich
February 23, 2011 at 8:46 pm
Jellicoe Road | One More Page
April 18, 2011 at 11:20 pm
I want to start a YA colony with Chelsea Connelly
October 6, 2011 at 3:51 pm
Review: Jellicoe Road by Melina Marchetta « Guy Gone Geek
October 10, 2011 at 6:11 am

{ 58 comments… read them below or add one }

Jenny March 19, 2010 at 5:38 am

WOW. This sounds amazing! Oh, and territory wars against the hipsters? Hello. I’m there.

Reply

porcelinajune March 19, 2010 at 11:03 am

I read this book last year but have completely forgotten most of the plot. I remember it being gorgously written. I do know I missed the characters aftewards. They reminded me of the characters in something like the movie Stand By Me where they are so real and you keep them in your heart forever.

Reply

Lysh March 19, 2010 at 2:08 pm

I get super excited when you ladies mark a book’s swoon level over a five. As soon as I saw the 9, I went to my library’s site and ordered it for myself. It sounds REALLY good! I can’t wait to read it.
And I would TOTALLY territory war against hipsters! xD

Reply

Meredith March 19, 2010 at 3:07 pm

Dang, did you write this review FROM SXSW?! You are dedicated, girl!

I am dying, dying, DYIIIIIING to read this now!!! Immediately!

Reply

Jill March 20, 2010 at 8:49 am

Sounds fantastic! Best review yet I’ve read for this book :)

Reply

nicky March 20, 2010 at 1:41 pm

a 9 on the swoonworthy scale?! is that a best-ever on fya? and now i’m dying to know what posh’s top five ya romances of all time are!

Reply

lily March 21, 2010 at 9:48 am

i’m dying to know too!
this book sounds amazing!! it’s now nº 1 on my TBR list!

Reply

Mia March 21, 2010 at 11:19 am

Didn’t this win a Printz award?

Reply

Meghan March 22, 2010 at 7:40 am

this book looks incredible. a 9 on the swoonworthy scale, secrets, boarding school, territory wars, mysterious loner dude? awesome.

Reply

Poshdeluxe March 22, 2010 at 7:53 am

i’m glad my swoonworthy rating is making waves cos Y’ALL NEED TO READ THIS STAT. and then come back here and comment so we can all gush about jonah.

nicky and lily, we will definitely be compiling a top YA romance list in the near future. stay tuned…

Reply

Maggie March 22, 2010 at 9:16 pm

OMG! Would totally be with you for Territory Wars. I actually just checked this book out of the library, I’m now thrilled to read it!!!!

Reply

Erin March 23, 2010 at 9:45 am

We had territory wars with the hippies at 21st street. Best way to make a hippie cry, y’all? Hang up a fresh deer-head carcas over the walk-in refrigerator where they keep their tofu.

I can’t wait to read this book!!!

Reply

Meredith April 5, 2010 at 3:58 pm

This book absolutely SLAYED me. I felt like I couldn’t catch my breath as I flew through it–the beauty, the mystery, the INTENSITY of Taylor and Jonah’s connection (YOWZA), and the depth of Taylor’s understandable darkness grabbed me so fiercely, I had to ignore life for 12 hours until I’d finished. This is probably my favorite YA book Sarah has ever loaned to me, and I preferred Jonah to Cameron Quick and Taylor to ANYONE, including Katniss. Even though I figured out every single facet of the mystery within the first 100 pages (I think maybe I’m a genius? Instead of it being super obvious? Because everything just fell into place in my mind in 5 seconds, revelation after revelation until I was jumping up and down repeating, “I figured it out! I know who they all are!”), it didn’t detract from my enjoyment in the slightest because the book is about so much more than the mystery. Taylor’s journey and the stunning prose made this book; the romance, intrigue, action and friendship (RAFFY! BEN!) were just the super tasty, ebullient frosting. I want to read it again IMMEDIATELY and I’m dying to read Marchetta’s other novels.

Also, I read it in a most gorgeous setting, sitting in a rocking chair on a cabin porch, overlooking acres of flowery fields with deer periodically frolicking their way over the fences–SIGH. My heart will never be the same.

Sarah, the crazy thing is that my two favorite books that you’ve ever loaned me, this and Special Topics in Calamity Physics, each had ethereal, mysterious, distant teachers to whom the main character is inextricably drawn, with NEARLY IDENTICAL NAMES! Hannah Schneider in Special Topics and Hannah Schroeder in Jellicoe Road! ISN’T THAT WEIRD?!

Reply

Poshdeluxe April 5, 2010 at 4:04 pm

seriously, is there any better feeling than loaning a favorite book to a friend and hearing that they love it as much as you do? ok, well, besides the feeling of actually *reading* the book.

YAY MEREDITH I’M SO SO SO SO HAPPY THAT YOU LOVED IT!!!!! i mean, i knew you would. but still. just knowing that there is one more person in this world who’s experienced the amazingness of jellicoe road makes me feel like i’ve done my good deed for the day (or even week!). behold the rewards of YAngelism!

and re: special topics, i had totally forgotten about the name connection! but i did think about that book when i was reading jellicoe… i don’t know if it’s the mystery or the heroine or what, but i feel like these books are definitely kindred spirits in AWESOMENESS.

Reply

Meredith April 6, 2010 at 1:51 pm

Just like us!

Reply

erin April 19, 2010 at 12:30 pm

OKAY. So this morning I had a meeting and then a client training and then had to work on this stupid endless presentation I’m giving tomorrow. And everyone keeps asking me if I’m sick, because my eyes are all red and I look tired.

YES. I AM SICK. I AM HEARTBROKEN BECAUSE JELLICOE ROAD HAS WRECKED ME.

I don’t even have words! Oh, taylor! Oh, Jonah! oh, Raffy and Chaz and Tate and Jude and Narnie and Webb. Oh Fitz. OH FITZ. And Jessa and Officer Santelego and! and!

I just want them all to be my friends. And I want to give them all hugs and some cocoa. They need it.

(Meredith, like you I figured out the connections pretty early – despite confusing Jude and Tate’s gender half the time, ha ha – but that just made it even more awesome to read.)

Oh! And that little throwaway at the end! About, um, the discovery of the person that Jessa is obsessed with! Way to go, Jonah’s dream father! (Not Jonah’s real father, obvs.)

Reply

erin April 19, 2010 at 12:32 pm

P.S. I totally want to have a territory war now!! Who’s going to fight me for the Prayer Tree??

Reply

Meredith April 19, 2010 at 4:20 pm

I KNOW, ERIN. I KNOW. heartstab!

Reply

Poshdeluxe April 20, 2010 at 12:30 pm

erin, i did the same thing with jude and tate (it’s like, finally we get some real names, but then they’re totally non-gender-specific!). and even though it’s easy to figure out who those people are, it doesn’t take away from the heartbreak and enchantment of this book. i’m so glad you loved it as much as i did!! YAY! let’s give them all hugs!! esp, um, jonah. lots of loooong hugs for jonah.

Reply

erin April 20, 2010 at 12:47 pm

Yes, I think I would be quite happy to give some long, lingering hugs to Jonah. I would actually sleep in a tent to be next to that boy and, like, I DO NOT CAMP.

Reply

Meghan April 21, 2010 at 11:32 am

OMG. i cannot go on with my life now that i’ve finished jellicoe road. jonah! jude! even raffy and that italian guy! oh, and i figured out the parallels pretty quickly, but i think marchetta did that deliberately. i felt like we were supposed to know what was going on as the book progressed, especially since the big reveals weren’t really big revelations to taylor, either. but OH MAN the serial killer one totally got me. like, jaw on the floor. and of course i cried (not about the serial killer, duh).

y’all, there need to be disclaimers on some books, like “DO NOT read this book before anything important, like work or an appointment or a big meeting or school, because you’ll either be super late because you couldn’t stop reading or you’ll show up with puffy, red eyes and a snotty nose (or both).”

Reply

Tammy May 19, 2010 at 10:36 am

Thank you so much for recommending this book. I read it in one day (thank you. I have no life) and I am experiencing TEABS. I’ve re-read my favorite parts over and over. I absolutely loved every character in the same way you all are saying. I wanted to hug them and tell them everything would be alright and as a mom (or maybe just as a human being) I cried for what some of them had gone through and for the ache Taylor felt in needing a family bond (and ultimately for remembering love). And hello Jonah Griggs. HOLY FREAKING COW. He was total hotness and the chemistry with Taylor had me from their first encounter. I almost fell off my sofa when he took her hand and held it to his chest. I audibly said “Swoon” and got a crazy look from my husband. But whatever because it was soooooo swoonworthy.

Reply

Poshdeluxe May 19, 2010 at 10:42 am

tammy, yr comment just made me want to read this book AGAIN. i’m so glad you loved it as much as i did! the fact that you literally said “swoon” out loud is, like, one of the highest compliments i can imagine for a novel.

sorry about the teabs though. it’s a pretty brutal case, and the only cure is time… and, ok, maybe a few jonah daydreams.

Reply

Deanne June 6, 2010 at 7:44 pm

Oh My Gosh! I loved reading this review! I always worry this book never recieved the recognition it deserved.
I read ‘On the Jellicoe Road’ back in 2006 and have read it MANY times since.
Melina Marchetta is an absolute genius!!!

Reply

Megan (no h) June 30, 2010 at 9:47 am

Ahhhhh I finally just read this! I loved it! Made me cry like a sucka’.

Reply

Poshdeluxe June 30, 2010 at 9:55 am

hey, even taylor cries. of course, she has a much harder life than we do. but then she gets jonah so…

now i’m crying again. CRYING WITH JEALOUSY.

Reply

Megan (no h) July 2, 2010 at 11:45 am

Yeah, Jonah actually requires me to hop in a time machine just so I can use the word HUNK to describe him.

Reply

Poshdeluxe July 2, 2010 at 11:48 am

dubs true, megan. that’s why i had to cast big rigs as jonah. cos no one can play a hunk like taylor kitsch. a hunk of SMOLDERING HOTNESS.

Reply

Jules July 2, 2010 at 10:17 am

Just discovered this blog…..utterly, unbelievabley fantastic book…I read this last year and felt like I went down a rabbit hole and I didn’t want to come back….read it in a day or two and after reading everyone’s comments, I may have to read it again….soooo good.

Reply

Tesla July 22, 2010 at 2:11 pm

I just discovered this site after reading The Hunger Games and acquiring a most severe case of the TEABS.

I picked up Jellicoe Road based on the high praise here. I’m so glad I did because it is a great book that I couldn’t put down! I would have spent all last night reading it but…Damn my 9-5 Job!

And this blog kicks ass – keep up the awesome work!

Reply

Poshdeluxe July 22, 2010 at 3:12 pm

tesla, the problem with jellicoe road is that it won’t cure yr TEABS, it will only prolong it. but you know, it’s the kind of disease that i think we can all learn to live with.

glad to have you around these YA-lovin’ parts!

Reply

Tesla July 23, 2010 at 9:02 am

Yeah, I thought Jellicoe Road would just be a nice distraction while waiting for Mockingjay. Now I have TEABS squared.
And the insertion of Tim Riggins into my visual of this book does not help with the withdrawal.

Seriously, I can’t get over how great his book was. I got sucked into YA through Harry Potter. But then Twilight left a nasty taste in my mouth. Thankfully, the Hunger Games, and now Jellicoe Road, have cleansed my palate. I’m looking forward to trying other books reviewed here!

Reply

Lex August 21, 2010 at 11:10 am

THIS WAS AAAAAAAMAZING. Definitely have to buy this one. I was pleasantly surprised by the sex, but then I remembered what one of my good friends (who went to school there) told me about Australia; being a virgin there isn’t like it is here. We are more likely to say “Good for you and your self-control!!!” whereas they are more likely to say “Seriously? NOT ONE PERSON wants to sleep with you???”

BUT I AM NOT COMPLAINING. It felt more realistic. YAY sexy jonah! And tunnels! And friendships! AND that little bit at the end about a certain person from that town that ends with the second-to-last letter from the alphabet!!!!

Reply

Poshdeluxe August 23, 2010 at 8:40 am

lex, so glad you enjoyed the book as much as i did!!!

and maybe when FYA starts raking in the millions, we can set up a foundation for american teenagers to spend high school in australia so they can return with higher self-esteem and a healthy sense of their sexuality.

that will happen AFTER we buy our luxury yacht, though. obvs.

Reply

Amber August 28, 2010 at 11:01 pm

I just read this book based on comments from FYA, and I friggin’ loved it. The first thing I thought when I finished the book was, “I am destroyed,” and I guess that’s the universal reaction since, in the comments, people have been “slayed” and “wrecked” by this book. I defy anyone to read this and disparage YA ever again. It’s crazy that it deals with all this tragic and serious stuff but still has light moments, especially when Taylor, Grigg(in)s, Raffy, and Santangelo hang out (the see-through nightie scene!!!).

Reply

Trish September 10, 2010 at 6:53 am

I adore this book and Jonah is my number one boy of YA.

Reply

Emily from Ohio September 27, 2010 at 9:59 am

I had to read this book for one of my library school classes, soon after it won the Printz. I have to say, I didn’t get it. At all. I didn’t cry once, I didn’t see any kind of swoon, and frankly, I cared more about the Fab 5 than I did about Taylor or Jonah or Raffy. I couldn’t figure out how it won the Printz over so many other, better books.

Then, I came across this site in June and I read through all the book reports. I read this book report, scoffed that people find bad books to be so good….. but then I read another book I never would have picked up on my own based on one of your reviews and I loved it. So I thought, maybe I should give Jellicoe Road another shot.

WOW. I 100% admit how WRONG I WAS. This book just rocks. There is one point in the middle where I was sobbing. I put the book down, curled up in a ball, and kept saying “I don’t ever want to feel like that. I don’t ever want to feel like that.” I love books that hit me in the gut this much. (The last book that had me sobbing in this way was “Jacob Have I Loved.”) There is definite swooning, but not just between Taylor & Jonah- I thought Raffy and Chaz had some nice tension too. And I love when Taylor tells off the police chief (Chaz’s dad, can’t remember his name)- FIST PUMP.

So, thank you FYA for showing me the error of my ways. I will never doubt you again.

Reply

Poshdeluxe September 27, 2010 at 3:27 pm

emily, this is my favorite reason ever to say I TOLD YOU SO.

Reply

Jesse October 4, 2010 at 10:18 am

I finished Jellicoe Road and loved it so much, I immediately reread it and then ordered it from amazon (because I had borrowed it from the library initially).

I can not recommend this book enough nor do I have much to add to poshdeluxe’s excellent and encompassing review. Except that I am down for a territory war.

Reply

Carrie Ann November 23, 2010 at 10:57 am

I started this book on the train ride to work yesterday and got about 25 pages in. Then I had to put it down for like 9 hours to, you know, WORK. Then I had to make dinner, do some laundry, and watch my stories.

Then I made the mistake of picking up the book at about 9:00 to start reading again. Friends, it was a long night. And I am very tired this morning. But I ask you — how was I supposed to put it down? What would have been a good spot to stop?

Right after they get thrown in jail and Taylor has an asthma attack and Jonah holds her tight and whispers in her ear to soothe her?
Or when he climbs in her window in the middle of the night?
Maybe after he kisses her during the party?
Maybe after they see the photos, and talk in the Prayer Tree about all of their trauma?

Right. There was no stopping the Jellicoe Road Express last night, but the TEABS are killing me today, and now I’m going to have to reread this book one million times until it becomes a part of me.

Reply

Michelle P December 3, 2010 at 7:39 pm

THANK YOU for suggesting this book. I’ve been reading this site for a few months and there have been enough references to Jellicoe Road that I finally picked it up. Like many of you, I found that I just had to read it all in one day… and it killed me every time I was interrupted! Major TEABS (love that term, thanks for that too!) – so much so that I literally just finished the book 15 min ago and immediately came to FYA to search for the review so that I could stay connected to Taylor, Jonah, and the rest of the crew for just a little longer through everyone’s comments.

Whoa. I feel like Taylor after an asthma attack – still can’t breathe clearly!!!

Reply

Joanna December 21, 2010 at 12:31 pm

You guys. I just finished this amazing book, and now that I can see through my tears I just had to say holy shizzz. I picked it up after seeing it mentioned here, and I have to admit that when I first started reading it I was totes confused. I didn’t get the timeline and the story of the five and how everything was going to connect and then suddenly, well, suddenly it all started making sense. And then I didn’t want to put it down. And then I cried like 27 times. That ending…holy effing TEABS.

As soon as I finished it, I gave it to a friend of mine who shares a passion for good books with a note on it that said “this book DESTROYED me. you must read it.” And then I will read it again when she gives it back.

Reply

Saran December 24, 2010 at 8:05 am

Isn’t it Gretchen Weiner’s hair that’s full of secrets?

Reply

Kaitlyn March 18, 2011 at 9:47 am

This book is so amazing, but I’m wondering have you guys read “Saving Francesca” which I got an ARC of several years back and is how I first heard of Melina Marchetta? It is my favorite, probably because I read it first, but also because it is 100% realistic fiction and this one is a little more dreamy/supernatural.

The love story is probably a 7 on the swoonmeter, but Will is definitely up there with Jonah. The book also features a kickass group of girlfriends. AND the sequel to SF (The Piper’s Son) just came out in the US.

Reply

Poshdeluxe March 18, 2011 at 11:25 am

Kaitlyn, YES, I loooove Saving Francesca. I’m actually planning on re-reading it and reviewing it on the site soon, so we’re, like, mindtwins! Let me guess– you’re also hankering for a mimosa right now?

Reply

Kaitlyn March 18, 2011 at 12:59 pm

How did you guess? Is it because it’s Friiiiiieeeeeday (partying, partying, yeah, yeah, yeah)?

Reply

Julia April 8, 2011 at 4:18 pm

TEABS. Oh such a bad case of TEABS

Reply

Annie S. April 8, 2011 at 8:00 pm

My angst over the Film-That-Must-Not-Be-Named drove me to, finally, to request Jellicoe Road from the library.

Oh. My. God.

I don’t think I’ve cried so much reading a book, like, ever, and I am an emotional crier. The epilogue. My God. JKR and Collins and Meyer need to take a page from Marcheta’s “How to Write an Ending that Doesn’t Totally Suck and Leaves the Reader Both Satisfied and in Tears.” Major, major TEABS.

I love you, Taylor Markham, maybe even more than I love the heroine of the Film-That-Must-Not-Be-Named. You are brittle and angsty and tough but you are also AWESOME in your weird love for those around you and your asthma and your strength. You’re unique yet relatable, you rock at chess, and I’m pretty sure you, me, and Raffy would have some killer times making fun of (and eyes at) the Townies and Cadets down at the scout hall.

Jonah Griggs needs no words. The dance scene was perfection.

And how about some love for Santangelo? I love how Marcheta told his and Raf’s story without actually telling it. Beautifully done.

Reply

Annie S. April 8, 2011 at 8:06 pm

I should also mention that I love that Taylor has a sense of humor. A wry sense of humor, but one nonetheless. A definite personality improvement over Katniss (whom I love, don’t get me wrong).

Reply

Tina April 19, 2011 at 10:41 pm

Major TEABS for sure. I don’t think any other contemporary novel will measure up to Jellicoe Road. Gah, the urge to reread it is so strong, I have to leave the book at home so I won’t do that…not yet, anyway. :)

Reply

Jamila6452 May 15, 2011 at 8:04 pm

I’ve heard you all mention this book so much since I started reading this site (around Mockingjay time), that I had to finally get Jellicoe Road out of the library. I read it yesterday (all in one day, natch) and reread most of it today. Oh my God. The TEABS. It is tearing me apart this time. What an incredible book. I feel the need to hogtie all of my friends down and make them read this so I have someone to swimfan over it with. Lacking that, I am googling and reading every review of it ever written and adding my own to goodreads and amazon, just so I can keep a connection to this book. I love it. I love Taylor. I love Jonah. I love Raffy and Chaz and Jude and Hannah and even annoying Jessa and creepy Hermit. I cannot let this book go.

Reply

Meg May 26, 2011 at 11:20 pm

I just want to sincerely thank you guys for writing about this book, or I never would have read it, or even known about it. I just read it cover to cover and sobbed intermittently throughout the last 100 pages or so. I can’t remember being this affected by a book in a looooong time and I have this awesome site to thank for it! So keep on keeping on.

Also, Jonah melted my panties right off.

Reply

Poshdeluxe June 2, 2011 at 12:41 pm

Meg, I seriously LIVE for comments like this. I’m so glad you experienced the wonderful incredible amazingness of this book. And, you know, the hotness of Jonah.

Reply

Xanda June 19, 2011 at 9:06 am

Oh my goodness, the TEABS. It’s been so long since I felt this way about a book. I’m currently in a bet with my boyfriend that I can read 80 books this summer, Jellicoe Road was #25 thus far. I have half a mind to just stop right there and read it over and over again to complete the 80. So so so incredible.

Thank you for reviewing it, because my life been made so much better because I read this book.

Now I must try to get everyone to read it. I’m not quite sure I’m prepared to loan it out though, cos I think I want to read it another 12 times and I can’t bear to be parted with it for that long of a time.

Reply

Trinity July 11, 2011 at 6:28 pm

That this book has been out there for so long and I’ve only just read it is almost unforgivable!
I know you warned about the TEABS but I was still not prepared!
There also needs to be a warning not to start this book before bed and to charge your ereader or 2am will make you oh so sad.
Jonah Griggs!!!!

Reply

Jess July 27, 2011 at 7:15 am

Holy.Effing.Shizz. This book was amazing. I am suffering from pretty much one of the worst cases of TEABS ever. I finished this book 5 days ago and am still having a hard time focusing on real life. And seriously, the noises and sobs coming out of me were undignified. So much so that hours later the husband asked if I was done crying yet.

Reply

Bonnie K October 6, 2011 at 6:19 pm

You GUYS. I have resisted posting on this because it is >1 year old and I don’t want to be that obnoxious person who posts hella late, but Y’ALL. I have reread this book at least five times since I first read it (…in June) and every single time I end up sobbing sniffling my way through at least the last 50 pages (there are some quieter tears earlier). I can’t even begin to describe how much I love this book. It blows my mind how much I love it every time I read it. It never gets old.

Reply

Sadie-Ann January 11, 2012 at 11:39 pm

I way, way, way late to the game but I finally finished reading this (my library doesn’t have it and I hadn’t gotten around to buying it until now) and now I’ve been crying for 10 minutes.

First The Book Thief and now this, stop making me read beautiful crying books.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: