REPORT CARD for The Book Thief by Markus Zusak
bff charm: yay!
swoonworthy scale: 4
talky talk: prosetastic
bonus factor: the grim reaper, Anne Frank
relationship status: til’ Death do us part
(guys, you are going to have to forgive me on this, but I’m pretty sure I won’t even be able to THINK about the book without crying, which means a suspicious lack of exuberant exclamation marks.)

the deal:
Death really hates his job, you guys. It’s no fun, collecting all those souls and winging them off to the great beyond. And in Germany in 1939, he’s starting to get stretched pretty thin.
But Leisel Meminger isn’t having it all that easy, either. Her baby brother dies, her Communist mother drops Leisel off to live with the Hubermanns in order to keep her from being taken to the death camps, her best friend wants to kiss her all the time, she’s hiding a Jew in the basement, and, even though she can’t really read, she seems to have an addiction to stealing books.
But Leisel is tough, and smart, and she’s surrounded by some amazing people, even during the height of Hitler’s reign over Germany, so maybe that’s why Death finds Leisel’s life so inspiring. And maybe that’s why Death, and I, grieve more than we should any time he has to claim the soul of someone Leisel loves.
bff charm: yay!

Oh man, you guys, I love Leisel so, so much. At the beginning of the book, she’s illiterate and short-tempered, more likely to punch someone in the face than help them out, and although she retains her awesome tomboyish ferocity, she also blossoms into a kind, caring, thoughtful teenager and adult. Not only would I love to be her BFF, but I would consider myself proud to know her.
And, can I add an additional category for Dad of the Decade? (Well, this is my book report, so I’m going to.) Cause you, Hans Hubermann, deserve the award:
the Cliff Huxtable award of Awesome Dadhood
Hans’ patient and gentle upbringing of Liesel is the sort of stuff that little kids (and grown adults) dream of. This book – beyond even the coming-of-age story, the thoughts of children in a nation at war, even the haunting and evocative narrative by Death – is a tender and heart-rending portrayal of the love a girl has for her father, and how both parent and child can make the other more than they would be alone. If I want to be best friends with Liesel, I want even more to be adopted by Hans Hubermann.
Except for the part where I’d have to live in Germany during WW2. But, you know, other than that part, plz adopt me, Hans!
swoonworthy scale: 4
Here’s the deal: Rudy Steiner is Liesel’s best friend, and he’s completely in love with her. In fact, he pretty much won’t shut up about it, and is constantly asking for a kiss. Liesel, on the other hand, isn’t that interested in being anything more than BFF. Liesel! I don’t think you’re seeing the potential here! Rudy steals food for your family to eat! And totally thinks you’re the best soccer (or “football” as those crazy Europeans call it) player around! And, FFS, he dressed up like Jesse Owens and ran around the village! How can you top that??
In the end, though, it’s Liesel and Rudy’s friendship which is far greater than any romantic relationship could be. Rudy is that best friend who lived down the street from you – the one who, growing up, would tell you that you threw like a girl and then make you play catch on the front lawn, the one who would put bugs on your shoulder to try and make you scream and then pretend that he didn’t really want to play with your Barbies, even as he was telling Skipper that the jacket she was wearing was all wrong with that shirt. I loved my own Rudy growing up, and reading The Book Thief brought back sweet memories for me.
talky talk: prosetastic
Markus Zusak is a poet, guys. I love the way he weaves the language of this book, through poetry by Death, Leisel and Rudy’s frank and vulgur gutter German, Max’s shy wisdom, Hans’ gravitas and Mama Hubermann’s irate cursing. Everyone in the book is so richly drawn, just by the language they use, and the overarching narrative gathers them all together in a finely-threaded lace.
Also, I love how the book is laid out; Death forshadowing the events of the book in his early narrative, and rich allegories of color and nature, which paint an absorbing and heartbreaking picture. Because a large part of this book is the power of words, it’s especially important that Zusak chooses his so well.
Bonus Factor: The Grim Reaper

It’s a book narrated by Death! What’s more awesome about that?! Answer: nothing
Second answer: not dying in WW2.
Bonus Factor: Anne Frank

Anne Frank has been making hiding Jews from the Nazis cool since the 1940s. In The Book Thief, the Hubermanns and Liesel hide Max, the Jewish son of Hans’s fellow WWI soldier, in their basement. In Max, Liesel has a confidante, a tutor and a face for the fight against the Fuhrer. And Max, like Anne Frank, spends his solitary, secluded time writing – only unlike Anne, he totally paints over the pages of Mein Kampf and writes his story over them. Ha! Take that, Adolf!
casting call:
You guys, this is HARD. Because I love this book so, so much, I would never want to see it made into a movie. Except how I would totally love to see it made into a movie. (Also: pretty sure it’s being made into a movie.)
evanna lynch as leisel
I love Evanna Lynch so much in the HP series, and I think she could stretch her acting chops and get a little less dreamy as Liesel. Plus, I’d love to see her punch someone in the face.
gary oldman from 20 years ago as Max
I love Gary Oldman; who doesn’t? And since I have a teeny-tiny crush on Max, and a not-so-teeny-tiny crush on Gary Oldman . . . and, okay, Gary Oldman is too old to play Max NOW, but if he were 20 years younger, he’d make an amazing Max.
I don’t even know where to start on Hans or Rudy. Anyone have any suggestions?
Relationship Status: til’ Death do us part
(Sorry, I couldn’t help it.)
Here are places not to read The Book Thief: planes.* trains. * automobiles. public park benches.* on the sofa at the house of a boy or girl you’ve just started dating and still want to impress. * at work. at school. in a restaurant. Or any other place where you may draw attention to your loud, heaving sobs. Cause, you guys, this book is CRAZY SAD. I read it on a transatlantic flight, and I thought the flight attendants were going to have to arrest me for air rage, cause I was bawling and moaning, “It’s just so wroooong! I hate you, Hitler! This is YOUR fault, do you hear me? Do you, Hitler?”
You aren’t going to escape this book unscathed. It will wreck you; this is fair warning. But it’s some of the most beautiful, amazing, rewarding wreckage you’ll ever experience. This is the kind of book that makes me grateful to be alive. It’s that good.
Really. I’m not overstating things here. IT IS THAT GOOD. If you haven’t read it yet, you’re doing yourself a disservice. Go out immediately, purchase it, go home and lock yourself in your house, make sure you’re stocked up on both ice cream and Visine, and be prepared to die a thousand amazing deaths. You can thank me later.
*I speak from experience.
No related posts.

{ 5 trackbacks }
{ 20 comments… read them below or add one }
holy smokes, erin, this is a doozy of a review. in fact, i now feel incredibly shallow given that all of my recent book reports have been about cute boys and kissing and trauma levels that OBVS CANNOT COMPARE to, you know, the holocaust.
of course i really need to read this book, but now i’m kinda scared. given yr warnings about all of the crying and the heartbreak and the inevitable red splotchy face, i don’t know if i can read it without the aid of my grandmother’s bathtub, where i retreated to finish “where the red fern grows” in third grade.
still, this book sounds worth all of the emotional wreckage, esp. cos i know from previous experience that true beauty breaks our hearts in order to increase our capacity to understand and appreciate it.
also, APPLAUSE for the cliff huxtable award. that’s officially an FYA keeper.
and i’m alls about evanna lynch.
Wow, I really need to read this book now. I wanted to read it after only seeing the cover, but now I *need need need* to!
Thanks for the heads up on potential bawling in public places. I will heed your advice, but this sounds like a book I won’t want to stop reading, no matter where I am. Great review!
Ack, I lost the comment I was working on! Okay, beautiful, stirring review and I second and third and fourth and fifth everything you said. I LOVE YOU, MAX! I LOVE YOU RUDY! I ESPECIALLY LOVE YOU, HANS! AND I ESPECIALLY, ESPECIALLY, ESPECIALLY LOVE YOU, LIESEL!
Great casting call for Liesel and Max. As for Rudy, I suggest this kid:
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1675002/
who was in a Supernatural episode and KILLED ME with his little tough guy antics: (Dean offered to go talk to some bullies for the kid, and the kid said, “Only BITCHES send grown-ups.” and Dean was all impressed: “You’re not wrong.”) and he totally has the energy and the wackily expressive eyebrows for Rudy.
As for Hans, who else but James Cromwell? I always totally cry and squee when I think of him being all, “That’ll do, pig,” so we know that his wise and stoic approval is ideal.
i’ve had this book on my to-read list for ages, too — now i really need to read it! it sounds so much better than i thought it would be, and thanks for the warning about public consumption. the last book that got me like that was the non-YA “art of racing in the rain” in my dentist’s office waiting room (PAGE 2! srsly?)
i really love this review, especially the stuff about making you grateful to be alive. sometimes we need that reminder, don’t we?
Alita, I sure didn’t want to stop reading. Except for when I had to, you know, when Shit Got Real. I don’t deal well with, like, sad things. (Also, welcome!)
Meredith currently has my copy, so ladies, borrow it from her. Well, um, except you, Meghan. You can just go to work and get it. (I say, with seething jealousy)
I’ll return it when we lunch on Friday!
Thanks for reviewing this! I’ve been putting off reading it, but now I feel like I MUST read it, and right away!
Also, the prose from death, where death is actually sad about taking people? wow.
Soo.. I went and got a copy of this at the bookstore – had to after your review. Needless to say I thought the blow would be slightly less due to “death’s” dislike of mystery and telling things ahead of time but man, I did not sleep very well the night I finished this. I woke up thinking I really need to go by a “happy” book immediately and read the whole thing – lol. Outside of that I have to agree that the book was absolutely AMAZING! I am very happy to have it as a part of my permenant book collection – I feel changed just by reading it and the style of writing just inspired me. Thanks for the review!!
Ha ha, I know what you mean, Tammy. I finished reading this on the flight home from London (already sad, cause, you know, who wants to leave London to come back to Texas. In summer.), and the only thing that would cure me was SkyMall!!
i had to come back and read this review after finishing the book today. i’m still a pretty big mess. books don’t make me cry very often.
for hans, i sort of imagine someone like michael caine or donald sutherland, but german. for rudy, i imagined someone like sean astin from his goonies days. definitely someone boyish, not rugged at all, and with a sense of goodness about him.
omigosh! I know I’m late to this review and reviving a dead comment chain but I had to agree with this review. I read this book a couple months ago and it took me quite a bit longer to read than most books because I had to keep setting it aside so I could absorb it slowly. I’m tearing up right now just thinking about Rudy and how he finally got his kiss. *deep sigh* I loved the mayor’s wife too. The secret connection she had with Leisel may have seemed small and inconvenient even but really had a huge impact on both of them. The emotional baggage was just so heavy between the two of them.
I also LOVED Zusak’s writing style. Each character had a voice that was unique from all the others. So many stories I read seem to have such generic voices and the only difference between character A and Character B is their name and hair color. But Zusak manages to use words to draw completely detailed and individual pictures of each character.
This book has a permanent spot on my bookshelf so that I can re-visit some old friends someday.
jill, your comment perked me up after a depressing football game last night.
I agree, I already can’t wait to read it again. why’d I have to go and loan it to everyone I know??
I know this is almos a year after you posted this but i just finished this book on my tropical vacation (it was weird, my mind was in ww II germany and my body was getting some tannage on a beach) and I LOVED IT!!! the writing is the best ive seen since some of those books we were assigned in high school, and the characters were utterly perfect. i loved death’s narration and comments.
i think that this review captures the book wonderfully!
I totally agree with the choice of evanna lynch but how about jim sturgess from across the universe as max? he sure has the scruffy, cute, pale thing down
i totally agree with i
wow so that didnt finish….what i meant to say:
i agree with evanna lynch as liesel but how about jim sturgess from across the universe as max? he sure has the scruffy, cute, pale thing down
erin, i FINALLY read this book, and wow. it’s the best book i’ve ever read. ever. i thought i had mockingjay teabs, but damn. i may never get over it, and never get over the sneaky sneaky things that happen where you think you’re prepared for something and then WHAM it’s a million times worse than you ever expected. and you’re so right about the writing — absolutely beautiful. if i’d been reading my own copy, i’d've filled it with pencil underlining.
I finally got around to reading this, and, yes. So good. So devastating. I kept crying for like an hour after I finished. And so beautifully written–I copied out whole sections into my Notebook of Good Words.
And next I am reading about 4 fluffy books–I don’t think one will do the trick.
So yeah, I’m pretty much a year and half behind the times here, but I just finished this book, like, five minutes ago and I remember that you guys had reviewed it at some point, so now I have to slightly revive the comment chain and say: I am. Sobbing. Like. A BABY.
Or, I was until about three minutes ago when I pulled myself together to see what you thought. Books like this need warning labels yo. Becuase if you’re o tlucky enough to swing by here and see the DNRIP tag, then the next thing you know, you’re sitting in you living room howling and scaring your dog.
I could make a million comments, but everyone above has already said pretty much everything I could say, so instead of restating the sheer levels of amazing (Rudy! Rosa! Max! HAAAANS! Liesel!!!) I will just say that this book is beautiful and heart breaking from beginning to end and needs to be on required reading lists of…the world. That is all.
You guys, I (since I love this book a crazy lot) just made my mom read it. And she has a heart of ice! She didn’t cry! She said she was way sad and heartbroken, but no crying. I sobbed so much I think I got dehydrated.
This book stayed with me soooooooooooooo long after I read it, it was like a I had a book shadow following me around in my subconscious. This was just a really, really beautiful book. This is one I always recommend to my family and friends.
My cousin gave me this book several years ago as a Christmas present, but I just can’t bring myself to read it. I’m sure it’s amazing and wonderful and all that, but I’m terrified that if I read it I’ll end up super depressed… I pretty much avoid reading anything that will make me cry. But the thing is, now that I think about it, some of the most life-changing amazing books that stay with me are the crying books…. Damnit, I think your review and my self-reflection have now convinced me to read the book. So if you don’t mind, I’ll be blaming my sobbing induced headache on you.